State Your Case: Stanley Cup Playoff chances of Stars, Avalanche
NHL.com writers debate which team is better situated for deep postseason run
Rosen: Why the Stars are Positioned for Success
The Dallas Stars have a strong scoring depth, led by forwards such as Jason Robertson, Matt Duchene, Roope Hintz, and Joe Pavelski. They have seven forwards with at least 40 points, providing the team with multiple offensive weapons.
In addition to their scoring depth, the Stars also have defenseman Miro Heiskanen, who can provide offensive contributions similar to Colorado's Cale Makar. Heiskanen has 37 points and adds an extra spark to the Stars' lineup.
Furthermore, the Stars have the assets and draft capital to make improvements before the trade deadline. With their aging core players, the team is willing to spend in order to maximize their chances of winning the Stanley Cup.
Van Diest: The Avalanche's Prime Core Players
The Colorado Avalanche possess a core group of players in their prime, including Nathan MacKinnon, Mikko Rantanen, and Cale Makar. These star players have consistently performed at a high level and can lead the team in a playoff series.
While the Avalanche may not have the same depth as the Stars, their top-end talent makes up for it. MacKinnon and Rantanen alone can dominate games and carry the team. Makar's contributions on defense further strengthen the Avalanche's chances.
Despite the Stars' depth, the Avalanche's core players in their prime give them an edge in the playoffs, where star power often shines.
Rosen: Addressing Concerns about Age
While the Stars' roster may have some aging players, such as Joe Pavelski and Jamie Benn, they have managed to defy expectations and continue producing at a high level. These experienced players bring valuable leadership and playoff experience to the team.
Moreover, the Stars' goaltending depth with Jake Oettinger and Scott Wedgewood provides them with a reliable tandem. Oettinger has already proven himself in the playoffs, helping the Stars reach the Western Conference Final last season.
Overall, the Stars' scoring depth, defensive contributions, and goaltending depth make them a strong contender in the playoffs, despite concerns about age.
Van Diest: The Power of Star Players
While the Stars may have depth, the Colorado Avalanche boast some of the league's best star players in Nathan MacKinnon, Mikko Rantanen, and Cale Makar. These players consistently produce and elevate their game during the playoffs.
In comparison, some of the Stars' top players, such as Matt Duchene and Joe Pavelski, are on the back end of their careers. The Avalanche's star power, combined with Makar's defensive contributions, gives them an advantage.
Additionally, the Avalanche's younger core players provide an energy and drive that can propel the team to success in the playoffs. Their ability to perform at a high level gives them an edge over the Stars.
